- Kumail Nanjiani arrived in the United States from Pakistan at 18 years old, attending Grinnell College in Iowa before pursuing entertainment in Chicago and Los Angeles
- His central thesis across all creative work: "no two immigrants have the same story"—a principle that applies equally to immigration legal strategy
- Nanjiani evolved from only playing "noble" immigrant characters to embracing complex, morally ambiguous roles—a shift reflecting maturation in immigrant representation
- Pakistani Americans are one of the largest groups of Muslim immigrants in the U.S., yet remain significantly underrepresented in media
- Trump-era travel bans directly impacted creative production, forcing "Little America" to film in Montreal
Kumail Nanjiani's journey from Pakistan to becoming one of Hollywood's most influential voices on immigration represents a fundamental truth about the American Dream—there is no single story. The Pakistani-American actor, comedian, and writer immigrated to Iowa to attend Grinnell College and has since used his platform to challenge stereotypes about immigrants while building an entertainment career that grossed $56.3 million with "The Big Sick" alone. For immigrants pursuing their own American Dream through work visas or green cards, personalized immigration support can make the difference between a stalled application and a successful outcome.
Kumail Nanjiani's Path to the American Dream
From Karachi to Iowa: The Early Years
Nanjiani's immigration story began when he left Karachi, Pakistan, to pursue higher education in the American Midwest. In his 2017 commencement speech at Grinnell College, he described watching his parents transform: "When I was a kid, I thought of my parents as these superheroes who knew everything... In the last ten years, I've seen them change in ways I never thought possible. They uprooted their lives and moved to America in their 50s, started over."
The culture shock of moving from one of Pakistan's largest cities to rural Iowa shaped his perspective on identity. Unlike many immigrant narratives that portray clear before-and-after transformations, Nanjiani's experience reflects ongoing complexity:
- Initial displacement: Arriving at 18 with limited understanding of American culture
- Academic adaptation: Studying computer science before pivoting to entertainment
- Family dynamics: Watching parents rebuild their lives while maintaining cultural expectations
- Career risk: Abandoning a "practical" path for comedy and acting
This willingness to take unconventional routes mirrors what many entrepreneurs and founders experience when pursuing visas that require demonstrating extraordinary ability or national interest.
The Identity Struggle That Persists
Perhaps most striking is Nanjiani's candid admission that integration remains incomplete even decades later. In interviews, he has stated he still struggles with my identity and he doesn't feel American nor Pakistani.
This liminal existence—belonging fully to neither origin nor destination—represents a reality many immigrants face but rarely see depicted authentically. His upbringing instilled the belief that body image issues contributed to decades-long struggles with food and physical expression that only recently became public through his dramatic physical transformation.
Breaking Barriers in Entertainment: Career Milestones
"The Big Sick" and Authentic Storytelling
The 2017 film "The Big Sick," which Nanjiani wrote with his wife Emily V. Gordon, represented a breakthrough in immigrant storytelling. Based on their real courtship—including complications from his Pakistani Muslim family's expectations around arranged marriage—the film demonstrated that authentic immigrant narratives could achieve commercial success.
The numbers speak for themselves:
- Production budget: $5 million
- Worldwide gross: $56.3 million
- Return on investment: 11x budget
- Critical reception: Oscar nomination for Best Original Screenplay
The film's approach to tackling real-life subject matter by spreading authentic moments throughout the narrative rather than concentrating them in climactic scenes created a blueprint for immigrant stories that feel lived-in rather than performative.
"Little America" and the Diversity Principle
Nanjiani's work as executive producer on Apple TV+'s "Little America" crystallized his philosophy about immigrant representation. The anthology series earned critics’ scores between 95% and 100% on Rotten Tomatoes, featuring radically different stories including:
- A 12-year-old Indian boy managing a motel after his parents' deportation
- A gay Syrian man fleeing persecution
- A Nigerian man pursuing his cowboy dreams in Oklahoma
- An Ugandan woman building a bakery empire
According to Nanjiani: "My immigrant experience was different from everybody else's immigrant experience... one of the thesis statements of the show is that no two immigrants have the same story."
This principle has direct implications for immigration legal services. Just as "Little America" rejected template-based storytelling, effective immigration strategy requires personalized approaches rather than one-size-fits-all solutions.
The "Good Immigrant" Narrative Problem
Why Merit-Based Empathy Falls Short
Critics have identified a troubling undercurrent in even progressive immigrant storytelling. Polygon's review observed that "Little America" follows "a rags-to-riches formula of hard work, and to some degree, conformity, being the path to triumph in America."
The Atlantic noted the series features "conspicuously hardworking immigrants, many of them entrepreneurs," which "can be a touch cloying." This reflects what critics call "the good immigrant" notion—the idea that immigrants deserve humane treatment because they've earned it through achievement rather than because they're human.
This narrative trap manifests in several ways:
- Achievement requirements: Stories focusing only on immigrants who start businesses or win awards
- Assimilation emphasis: Characters succeeding by adopting American cultural norms
- Trauma justification: Using suffering as evidence that immigrants "deserve" acceptance
- Economic contribution framing: Valuing immigrants primarily for what they produce
For immigration legal services, awareness of this harmful framework ensures that client communications and marketing don't inadvertently reinforce the idea that only "deserving" immigrants merit assistance.
Evolution Toward Complex Characters
Nanjiani's own journey reflects a philosophical shift away from noble-only representation. When first offered "Welcome to Chippendales" in 2017 during Trump's travel ban, he hesitated: "I didn't know whether me playing an Indian immigrant who's such a bad guy was the right thing to do... I worried that playing 'a brown guy who does bad things might not help the cause.'"
By the time the project returned, his perspective had transformed: he wanted to play complex, layered characters rather than "noble characters." The series earned five Emmy nominations, validating that audiences appreciate fully realized immigrant characters.
How Immigration Policy Shaped Creative Production
The Travel Ban's Real-World Impact
The Trump administration's Muslim travel ban directly affected "Little America" production in ways that illustrate how policy extends beyond legal status. The Syrian episode had to be filmed in Montreal because the travel ban prevented key collaborators from reaching the U.S. set.
Gordon noted the bitter irony: "And here we are, trying to make a series about how welcoming and great America is."
These production challenges demonstrate why maintaining proper immigration status matters beyond personal circumstances—it affects:
- Business operations and creative collaboration
- International project timelines
- Cultural exchange opportunities
- Career trajectory and professional reputation
For artists and entertainers pursuing work in the U.S., understanding visa options like the O-1B for individuals with extraordinary ability in the arts becomes essential.
The Representation Gap in Prior Casting
Perhaps the most striking discovery during "Little America" casting came when producers encountered actors who had exclusively played "Terrorist number one" or "terrorist number two" and had never played characters who simply "walked into a room and had groceries to make a meal for their family."
This casting reality underscores how limited opportunities have been for immigrant actors and why projects like "Little America" matter for shifting industry norms.
Supporting Your Immigration Journey
Different Pathways to the United States
Nanjiani's story—arriving on a student visa and building a career that would eventually support various immigration pathways—reflects one of many routes immigrants take. Common pathways include:
- Student visas (F-1): Initial entry for higher education, as Nanjiani used
- Work visas (H-1B, O-1): Employment-based authorization for specialty occupations or extraordinary ability
- Green cards: Permanent residency through employment (EB categories) or family sponsorship
- Naturalization: The path to citizenship through residency requirements and the N-400 application
For those in creative fields, the O-1A visa for extraordinary ability or O-1B for arts and entertainment provides pathways that recognize achievement without requiring traditional employer sponsorship.
Why Technology Matters in Immigration
Modern immigration requires managing complex documentation, tracking deadlines, and maintaining compliance across potentially years-long processes. HuffPost observed that immigrant stories share "the unyielding desire to keep moving forward and succeed"—but that persistence requires systems that don't let paperwork derail progress.
Key compliance considerations include:
- Document tracking: Maintaining records for visa extensions and status changes
- Deadline management: Filing renewals before authorization expires
- Status monitoring: Understanding work authorization limitations
- Application preparation: Compiling evidence for extraordinary ability or national interest claims
Alma's platform addresses these challenges through built-in trackers, proactive alerts, and audit-ready records that keep applicants informed throughout their case.
The American Dream Reimagined
Nanjiani's experience challenges simplistic American Dream narratives. Success didn't come through abandoning his Pakistani identity or conforming to expectations—it came through authenticity, persistence, and willingness to take creative risks.
In his reflection, watching his parents restart their lives in their 50s transformed his understanding of what immigration requires. The American Dream isn't a single destination but an ongoing process of building, adapting, and contributing.
For those beginning their own immigration journey, the lesson from Nanjiani's story is clear: your path won't look like anyone else's. What matters is finding the right support—legal, professional, and personal—to pursue it effectively.
Ready to explore your immigration options? Start your free consultation with Alma's attorney-led team.
Frequently Asked Questions
For entertainers with significant career achievements, the O-1B visa for individuals with extraordinary ability in the arts is typically most appropriate. This category requires demonstrating sustained national or international acclaim through evidence like awards, critical reviews, high salary, and significant contributions to the field. Unlike H-1B visas, O-1 visas don't have annual caps and allow for more flexible employment arrangements—particularly valuable for actors and comedians who work across multiple projects and studios.
Immigration restrictions create ripple effects throughout production timelines, casting decisions, and international collaboration. When travel bans prevent crew members or actors from entering the country, productions face costly location changes, schedule delays, and compromised creative vision. Studios increasingly factor immigration complexity into project planning, sometimes choosing international filming locations or casting based partly on visa accessibility rather than purely artistic considerations.
Beyond traditional casting channels, emerging opportunities include streaming platforms actively seeking diverse content, production companies founded by immigrants specifically to create authentic representation, and anthology series like "Little America" that deliberately showcase varied immigrant experiences. Industry organizations offer mentorship programs, and some immigration attorneys specialize in entertainment industry visas, understanding the unique documentation requirements for demonstrating extraordinary ability in creative fields.
Most green card holders become eligible to apply for naturalization after five years of continuous permanent residence (or three years if married to a U.S. citizen). The naturalization process itself—from N-400 application through citizenship ceremony—typically takes about 5–10.5 months nationwide in recent USCIS data. Maintaining proper documentation of residence, travel, and tax compliance throughout the green card period simplifies the eventual citizenship application.
Career changes don't inherently harm immigration applications, but they require careful documentation. For employment-based visas, demonstrating continued qualification in your field matters. Transitioning from computer science (Nanjiani's original major) to entertainment wouldn't disqualify someone, but they'd need to show achievement in their new field. For extraordinary ability categories like O-1 or EB-1A, evidence from your actual career path—regardless of how unconventional—determines eligibility.
Pegah Karimabakhsh Asli is an Associate Attorney at Alma, where she advises startups, founders, and enterprise clients on a wide range of employment-based immigration matters. She has extensive experience preparing and filing petitions across key categories, including TN, H-1B, L-1, O-1, EB-1, NIW, and Adjustment of Status (AOS), and provides strategic counsel to clients navigating complex immigration pathways.
Before joining Alma, Pegah worked at Fragomen in Silicon Valley, where she supported multinational corporations and high-growth companies with business immigration strategy and case management.
Jihan (Jina Hassan) Merlin is an Immigration Attorney and Head of Immigration Strategy at Alma, where she leads efforts to build smarter, faster, and more human immigration solutions. With over a decade of experience advising individuals, startups, and Fortune 100 companies, she combines legal expertise with technology to design scalable immigration programs. A graduate of Boston College Law School, Jihan is passionate about innovation in process and improving every stage of the immigration journey.
Want to fast-track your immigration journey?
.png)
.png)
