%20(2)%20(1).png)
- Statutory caps severely limit admissions – Due to numerical caps established in 1921, the U.S. admitted only 3.8% of would-be immigrants in 2023 according to Cato
- Institute analysis, compared to 98% admission rates before caps existed. This reflects systemic limitations rather than application adjudication outcomes, which have substantially higher approval rates
- Processing location dramatically impacts outcomes – Consular offices abroad deny 61% of applications versus just 8% denial rates for domestic adjustment of status, making location strategy critical
- Employment-based categories face unprecedented scrutiny – EB-2 NIW rates plummeted from 79.99% in FY 2023 to 43.31% in FY 2024, while EB-1A rates declined from 70.50% to 60.65%
- Professional representation matters more than ever – With Alma's immigration services maintaining a 99%+ approval rate through expert preparation, comprehensive documentation, and attorney-led petitions, applicants significantly improve their chances
- Processing times continue extending – Processing reached 3.4 years for employer-sponsored green cards by 2025, with backlogs exceeding 1.8 million cases
- Complete applications remain critical – While USCIS may deny applications missing required initial evidence, 2021 policy guidance encourages officers to issue RFEs or NOIDs when appropriate, though complete submissions remain the best practice
Comprehensive data compiled from USCIS reports, State Department analyses, and immigration policy research
Overall Green Card Denial Rates and Trends (2019-2024)
- Statutory caps limited admissions to 3.8% of would-be immigrants in 2023, representing systemic barriers rather than case rejections. Cato Institute analysis estimates the U.S. admitted only 3.8% of would-be immigrants in 2023 due to numerical caps established in 1921, not individual application deficiencies. Before caps existed, an average of 98% of immigrants were admitted annually. Actual USCIS adjudication approval rates for filed applications are substantially higher and vary by category—this 3.8% figure reflects systemic limitations on how many people can immigrate, not how many applications are approved when adjudicated.
- Green card processing times reached an all-time high of 3.4 years for employer-sponsored applications. Research shows processing durations extended to nearly three-and-a-half years by 2025, adding over 18 months since 2016. This bureaucratic expansion creates uncertainty for applicants and employers alike, making efficient preparation essential. Professional services like Alma's employment-based green card platform streamline document preparation with guaranteed two-week turnaround times, helping applicants avoid preventable delays.
- The employment-based green card backlog grew to 1.8 million pending cases as of March 2023. USCIS data reveals massive backlogs with about 1.8 million applications awaiting adjudication. This overwhelming volume strains resources and extends processing times across all categories. The backlog particularly impacts applicants from countries facing per-country limits, creating multi-year waits even for approved petitions.
- 6.3 million green card slots have gone unused since 1921 due to administrative failures. Analysis shows 6.3 million cap spots were wasted through bureaucratic inefficiency over the past century. These lost opportunities represent potential permanent residents who could have contributed to the U.S. economy. The administrative waste underscores the importance of working with experienced immigration professionals who navigate the system efficiently.
Employment-Based Green Card Denial Statistics
- EB-2 National Interest Waiver approval rates collapsed from 79.99% in FY 2023 to 43.31% in FY 2024. The EB-2 NIW category experienced a staggering 46% decrease in approvals within a single fiscal year. This dramatic shift reflects increasingly stringent adjudication standards and heightened scrutiny on national interest claims. Applicants now require stronger evidence of their proposed endeavor's substantial merit and national importance. Alma's EB-2 NIW services help applicants build comprehensive cases with expert attorney guidance to navigate these elevated requirements.
- EB-1A Extraordinary Ability approval rates declined from 70.50% in FY 2023 to 60.65% in FY 2024. Data shows EB-1A approvals dropped by nearly 10 percentage points year-over-year. Despite this decline, EB-1A still maintains higher approval rates than EB-2 NIW in the current environment. This category requires demonstrating sustained national or international acclaim through extensive documentation of achievements.
- EB-2 NIW denial rates exceeded EB-1A rates for the first time in FY 2025 Q1. Recent statistics reveal NIW denials reached 37.2% compared to EB-1A's 25.1% in the first quarter of fiscal year 2025. This reversal represents a significant shift in relative difficulty between categories. The trend suggests adjudicators now apply more rigorous standards to NIW petitions than previously.
- Employment-based green cards processed domestically face only 9-10% denial rates for completed applications. USCIS data shows approximately 9-10% denial for employment-based applications filed within the United States in FY 2024. This relatively moderate denial rate for domestic adjustment demonstrates that well-prepared applications with qualified applicants achieve high success rates. The key factor separating approved from denied cases is typically documentation quality and legal preparation.
Top Reasons for Green Card Application Denials
- Incomplete documentation and missing required evidence can lead to denials. USCIS officers may deny applications when required initial evidence is missing; however, 2021 policy guidance encourages issuance of Requests for Evidence (RFEs) or Notices of Intent to Deny when appropriate. This places responsibility on applicants to submit complete, comprehensive packages initially. Missing birth certificates, marriage certificates, medical examinations, or financial documentation can result in denials. Alma's immigration platform provides guided workflows and comprehensive checklists to ensure all required documentation is submitted correctly the first time.
- Immigration status violations and unauthorized employment frequently cause I-485 adjustment denials. Legal analysis reveals that maintaining valid status ranks among the most common denial reasons for employment-based and family preference applicants. Unauthorized work, overstaying visas, or gaps in legal status can render applicants inadmissible. Even brief periods of unauthorized employment can jeopardize entire cases. Applicants must maintain continuous lawful status from initial entry through green card approval.
- Criminal history, prior immigration violations, and health concerns trigger inadmissibility findings. State Department data confirms multiple grounds of inadmissibility can result in permanent bars to immigration. Criminal convictions involving moral turpitude, drug offenses, or aggravated felonies create serious obstacles. Prior immigration violations like fraud, misrepresentation, or unlawful presence can trigger multi-year bars. Certain communicable diseases or failure to obtain required vaccinations also cause denials.
Consular Processing vs. Domestic Adjustment Success Rates
- U.S. consulates abroad deny 61% of employer-sponsored immigrant visa applications. Analysis shows consular processing denials of 61% for employment-based applications processed at overseas posts. This exceptionally high rejection rate contrasts sharply with domestic processing success rates. Consular officers exercise broad discretion in visa adjudications, with decisions difficult to appeal or review. Administrative processing delays and additional security screenings frequently extend consular cases for months or years.
- USCIS approves 92% of employer-sponsored immigrants adjusting status within the United States. Comparative data reveals only 8% denial rates for adjustment of status applications filed domestically with USCIS. This dramatic difference—61% consular denials versus 8% USCIS denials—demonstrates the critical importance of processing location strategy. Applicants already in the United States with valid status should strongly consider domestic adjustment when eligible. Alma's legal team helps companies and employees determine optimal processing strategies based on individual circumstances.
Family-Based Green Card Denial Patterns
- Family-based green card applications face approximately 10% denial rates in FY 2024. Statistics show 10% of petitions are denied annually when processing reaches adjudication. Common denial reasons include insufficient evidence of bona fide relationships for marriage-based cases, inability to demonstrate required family relationships, or financial inability to meet affidavit of support requirements. Recent policy changes allowing denials without RFE opportunities increase the importance of comprehensive initial submissions.
Request for Evidence (RFE) Response and Attorney Representation Impact
Professional legal representation significantly impacts application outcomes, particularly when responding to Requests for Evidence. While comprehensive RFE statistics aren't publicly available in the research data, the dramatic difference between DIY applications and attorney-prepared petitions is evident in overall approval rates.
Alma's 99%+ approval rate across employment-based categories demonstrates the value of expert preparation. This success stems from:
- Comprehensive initial documentation eliminating RFE triggers
- Strategic evidence presentation addressing adjudicator concerns
- Attorney expertise in legal standards and precedent decisions
- Proactive case strengthening before submission
- Professional RFE responses when additional evidence is requested
The platform's built-in compliance tracking, automated reminders, and attorney oversight ensure nothing falls through the cracks during the application process.
Frequently Asked Questions
The answer depends significantly on application category and processing location. Admission rates reached lows due to statutory caps, though this reflects systemic limitations rather than individual case merit. For applications that reach adjudication, employment-based and family-based categories each face approximately 10% denial rates domestically. However, consular processing shows 61% denial for employer-sponsored cases, making processing location a critical strategic decision.
While direct comparative statistics aren't available in government data, the evidence strongly supports professional representation. Alma's 99%+ approval rate across employment-based categories far exceeds average success rates, demonstrating the impact of expert preparation. Attorneys prevent common errors, ensure comprehensive documentation, strategically present evidence, and provide effective RFE responses. Given NIW rates dropped to 43.31% overall but Alma maintains 99%+ success, professional representation clearly influences outcomes significantly.
Based on FY 2024 data, EB-1A maintains 60.65% approval compared to EB-2 NIW's 43.31%, making EB-1A the stronger category currently. However, these statistics represent all applications including self-filed and poorly prepared cases. With expert guidance through Alma's EB-1A services, qualified applicants achieve far higher success rates. The choice between categories should depend on individual qualifications rather than solely on aggregate statistics, as a well-prepared EB-2 NIW with strong national interest evidence may succeed where an underdeveloped EB-1A fails.
Yes, reapplication is generally possible after addressing the denial reasons, though specific circumstances vary. If denied due to missing documentation, status violations, or insufficient evidence, applicants can file new petitions with corrected issues. However, denials based on inadmissibility grounds like criminal history or immigration fraud create more substantial barriers potentially requiring waivers. Alma's legal team provides free consultations to assess denial reasons and develop strategic reapplication plans. The Growth and Enterprise business plans include one free refile if initial denial occurs, demonstrating confidence in application quality.
Travel with a lost green card requires obtaining emergency documentation before departure. Applicants abroad who lost their green cards need a boarding foil (Form I-131A) from the nearest U.S. embassy or consulate to return. This temporary travel document permits a single entry back to the United States. Domestic applicants should file Form I-90 to replace the card before traveling internationally. Processing times for I-90 replacements average 11 months, making advance planning essential for any international travel.
Pegah Karimabakhsh Asli is an Associate Attorney at Alma, where she advises startups, founders, and enterprise clients on a wide range of employment-based immigration matters. She has extensive experience preparing and filing petitions across key categories, including TN, H-1B, L-1, O-1, EB-1, NIW, and Adjustment of Status (AOS), and provides strategic counsel to clients navigating complex immigration pathways.
Before joining Alma, Pegah worked at Fragomen in Silicon Valley, where she supported multinational corporations and high-growth companies with business immigration strategy and case management.
Jihan (Jina Hassan) Merlin is an Immigration Attorney and Head of Immigration Strategy at Alma, where she leads efforts to build smarter, faster, and more human immigration solutions. With over a decade of experience advising individuals, startups, and Fortune 100 companies, she combines legal expertise with technology to design scalable immigration programs. A graduate of Boston College Law School, Jihan is passionate about innovation in process and improving every stage of the immigration journey.
Want to fast-track your immigration journey?
.png)
.png)
.png)
.jpg)
