Choosing between TN Visa and H-1B Visa: A Comparison

The TN and H-1B visas are two important pathways for professionals seeking to work in the United States. Each option comes with distinct requirements, benefits, and limitations that can significantly impact your career journey.

Canadian and Mexican professionals often face the critical decision of which work visa best suits their situation. Similarly, U.S. employers recruiting talent from these countries need to understand which visa aligns with their hiring needs and timeline expectations.

Get a complete comparison of TN and H-1B visas, along with the pros and cons of each, to find the best visa option for your needs.

Key Takeaways:

• The eligibility requirements for TN and H-1B visas, and which professionals qualify for each.
• Key differences in application processes, timing, and costs affect employers and employees.
• Overview of how each visa impacts job mobility, green card compatibility, and long-term immigration planning.
• The advantages and limitations of each visa to help you determine which option best fits your situation.

What are TN and H-1B Visas?

The TN and H-1B visas are temporary work permits that allow foreign professionals to work legally in the United States. While they serve similar purposes, they operate under different rules and benefit different groups of applicants.

The TN visa (Trade NAFTA, now part of USMCA) is a special category created specifically for Canadian and Mexican citizens under the North American trade agreements. It provides a path for certain professionals listed in the agreement to work temporarily in the United States. Unlike the H-1B, the TN visa has no annual cap and offers a potentially faster application process, especially for Canadians.

The H-1B visa is a temporary work permit for professionals in specialty occupations that typically require a bachelor's degree or higher. This visa allows U.S. companies to employ foreign workers in fields like technology, engineering, medicine, finance, and education. The H-1B is available to citizens of any country but is subject to annual caps and a lottery system.

Note: Some employers are exempt from the H-1B cap. These include higher education institutions, nonprofit organizations connected to higher education, nonprofit research groups, and U.S. government research institutions.

Who can Apply for a TN or H-1B Visa?

Before getting into the application process, it's important to understand the basic eligibility criteria for each visa type. The requirements differ significantly and will immediately eliminate certain options for many applicants.

Each visa has its own set of rules about who can apply and what kind of job qualifies.

Here are some examples of who can qualify for the TN visa and the H-1B visa:

• A Canadian software engineer with a bachelor’s degree in Computer Engineering and a job offer from a U.S. tech firm can qualify for either TN or H-1B.
• An Indian data scientist with a master's degree who receives a job offer from a U.S. company can only apply for the H-1B visa, as the TN visa is exclusively for Canadian and Mexican citizens. Many technology professionals from India use the H-1B pathway to work in the United States.

Differences in the Application Process of TN and H-1B Visas

The application procedures for TN and H-1B visas differ substantially, especially for Canadian citizens. Understanding these differences can help you anticipate timelines and prepare the necessary documentation.

The TN visa process is generally faster and simpler, while the H-1B involves more steps and potentially a lottery system that can introduce uncertainty into your plans.

Here’s a quick view of how each process works:

For non-USCIS TN petitions, Canadian citizens can apply directly at the U.S. border (port of entry) or airport pre-flight inspection. Mexican citizens must first attend a visa interview at a U.S. consulate. H-1B beneficiaries must go through a lottery if applying under the regular cap.

The TN can mean faster start dates and less paperwork for companies hiring Canadian talent in a qualifying role. However, for others looking for more travel flexibility during the green card process, an H-1B visa is a better option.

How Long Each Visa Lasts and What Renewal Looks Like

The duration of your legal work status and the conditions for extending it significantly impact your career planning and personal life. While both visas are temporary, they offer different timelines and pathways for continued employment in the U.S.

Understanding these differences is crucial for making decisions that align with your long-term goals.

Professionals who plan to live in the U.S. permanently often find the H-1B more aligned with long-term plans due to its compatibility with green card applications. On the other hand, the TN visa works better for those who want to work short-term or don’t yet plan to apply for a green card.

Eligible Job Categories Under H-1B and TN Visas

Job classification plays a critical role in determining visa eligibility. The TN visa is limited to specific professional categories defined in the USMCA agreement, while the H-1B covers a broader range of specialty occupations.

Understanding where your profession fits can prevent application denials and help guide your visa strategy.

Here’s a quick overview of some of the common job categories that may qualify under TN visa and H-1B visa categories:

Examples of jobs that qualify under TN:

• Engineers: Including civil, electrical, software, and other engineering disciplines.
• Accountants: Certified public accountants and other accounting professionals.
• Teachers: College-level instructors in various subjects.
• Scientists: Biologists, chemists, and research professionals.
• Medical professionals: Physicians, nurses, and certain therapists (but not all medical fields).
• Some management consultants: Those who have a specific educational background and experience.

Examples of jobs not covered under TN but often approved for H-1B:

• Marketing managers: Marketing positions generally don't qualify for TN.
• HR professionals: Human resources positions aren't included in the TN list.
• Product managers: This common tech role doesn't fit the TN categories.
• Financial analysts: Unless they can be classified under a different USMCA role.

Cost Comparison: TN Visa vs. H-1B Visa

The financial aspects of visa applications can be significant for both employers and employees. Understanding the cost structure helps with budget planning and can influence which visa route makes the most economic sense.

The TN visa offers a more cost-effective option, making it attractive for companies with tight budgets or consultants who may bear their own application costs.

Here are some of the cost-related differences:

Companies often prefer TN when it applies due to lower legal and filing fees, which can save thousands of dollars per employee. However, H-1B might be worth the additional investment if the employee plans to stay long-term or pursue a green card.

Job Mobility: Changing Employers or Roles

The ability to change jobs or advance your career while maintaining legal status is an important consideration. The two visa types offer significantly different levels of flexibility when it comes to professional mobility.

This makes the H-1B more suitable for people expecting to change roles, grow into new titles, or switch companies within the U.S. technology sector, where job changes are frequent.

Green Card Compatibility

For many professionals, a work visa serves as an important step toward permanent residency. The compatibility of your visa with green card applications can significantly impact your long-term immigration strategy.

This is one of the most important differences between the two visa types and often becomes the deciding factor for those with permanent immigration goals.

Tip: Some professionals handle this challenge by switching from TN to H-1B status before beginning the green card process. This strategy requires careful timing and planning.

However, anyone looking to apply for a green card in the future will often choose the H-1B from the start to avoid these complications, even if the TN would be easier to obtain initially.

Pros and Cons of the TN Visa

The TN visa offers a fast and simple way for Canadian and Mexican citizens to work in the U.S., but it comes with specific limits.

Pros of TN Visa:

• Quick approval process: Canadian citizens can apply at the border without waiting for petition approval, which helps start jobs faster.
• Lower costs: Fewer government and legal fees are involved, making it more affordable for both the applicant and employer.
• No lottery or cap: Applications can be submitted at any time of year, avoiding the risk and delay of the H-1B's annual lottery system.
• Renewable with no limit: As long as the job continues and remains eligible, the TN visa can be extended repeatedly.
• Ideal for short-term assignments: Useful when the role is temporary or the person doesn’t plan to stay in the U.S. long-term.

Cons of TN Visa:

• Only for Canadian and Mexican citizens: People from other countries can’t apply, which limits who can use this option.
• The job must match the NAFTA list: Only specific professions are allowed. If the job title doesn’t match, the visa may be denied.
• No self-employment: Starting a business or working as a contractor.
• No dual intent: Applying for a green card while on TN status can cause issues with renewals or reentry because the visa assumes you plan to return home.

These limits make TN a better fit for shorter stays, simpler job structures, or cases where permanent U.S. residence isn’t the goal.

Pros and Cons of the H-1B Visa

The H-1B visa supports skilled workers in a wide range of industries, and it’s often chosen by those with long-term goals in the U.S. But it also involves more steps and rules.

Pros of H-1B Visa:

• It supports a wider range of jobs: Most roles that require a college degree or higher qualify, including tech, marketing, and finance. This makes it more flexible for both applicants and employers.
• Dual intent allowed: You can apply for a green card while on an H-1B without hurting your visa status, which helps those with permanent U.S. plans.
• Cap-exempt options exist: If the job is at a nonprofit, university, or research group, it may be exempt from the annual cap, avoiding the lottery.
• Allows job changes without leaving: Workers can switch employers without needing to leave the U.S., helping them grow their careers more freely.
• Spouses may become eligible for work authorization in some circumstances: If the H-1B principal has an approved I-140, H-4 dependent spouses can apply for work authorization documents (H-4 EADs), helping dual-career families.

Cons of H-1B Visa:

• Lottery process adds risk: Most new applicants must go through a random selection each year, and not everyone gets picked.
• Higher fees and legal steps: Employers must file more paperwork and pay multiple government fees, which can slow down hiring.
• Takes longer to start: Compared to TN, H-1B processing time can take weeks or months, which delays start dates.
• Limited stay without green card path: The total stay usually ends after six years unless certain milestones are reached in the green card.
• Strict employer rules: Changes in job location, duties, or pay often require updates to filings, which adds compliance work.

H-1B works better for those in jobs not covered by TN, or for people planning to stay long-term and apply for permanent residence.

Can You Maintain Both TN and H-1B Visa Status?

A person cannot hold both TN and H-1B status at the same time. Each visa gives a separate legal status, and only one can be active at once. It’s possible to switch from one to the other, but both can’t be active at the same time.

In some cases, someone may have their employer apply for both as “consular” petitions and decide which one to activate based on timing, employer needs, or future plans. The person would need to choose either visa while entering the U.S., which would become the active status.

For example, the employer of a  Canadian engineer may file an H-1B change of status or consular petition while the engineer is already working on a TN. Once the H-1B is approved, a switch can happen, either by leaving the U.S. and re-entering or through a change of status request inside the U.S.

Here are some things to consider if thinking about holding both options:

• Only one visa status can be used at a time. Your most recent I-94 record determines your current status.
• A new I-94 (arrival/departure record) will show which status is active. This happens after travel or a USCIS change of status approval.
• Switching from TN to H-1B may support long-term plans, especially for those considering green card applications.
• If plans change or delays happen, having both options can provide flexibility during uncertain times like the H-1B cap season.

Always use the correct status that matches the current job and visa type. Using the wrong one could cause issues with legal stay or work rights.

TN or H-1B: Which Visa Option Should You Choose?

Selecting the right visa requires evaluating your unique circumstances, including your citizenship, profession, long-term goals, and employer's needs. Consider these example scenarios to help identify which visa might be more suitable for your situation:

• Canadian professionals in eligible fields: The TN visa offers a fast, low-cost way for Canadian citizens with job offers in USMCA-listed professions to start working quickly.
• Mexican professionals with long-term goals: H-1B is usually the preferred option for Mexican citizens who want to live in the U.S. long term, despite its more complex process.
• Companies hiring Canadian talent: Choosing TN can help HR teams avoid cap limits and save time and money when hiring Canadian professionals for eligible roles.
• Professionals with permanent residency plans: H-1B provides more flexibility and security during the permanent residency process for those planning to apply for a green card within the next few years.
• Professionals in non-USMCA occupations: H-1B may be the only viable option for those whose jobs don't appear on the USMCA list, regardless of citizenship.

The right decision often involves weighing immediate needs against long-term goals. For instance, one can now choose TN for its speed and simplicity, with plans to switch to H-1B when pursuing permanent residency.

How Alma can Help You in the TN and H-1B Visa Application Process

Work visa decisions can feel complex, especially when speed and long-term plans are both important. Alma helps simplify the entire process. Whether choosing between TN and H-1B, Alma helps people and companies make the right call, prepare strong petitions, and move fast.

Here’s how Alma can support you throughout the entire process efficiently:

• Expert visa assessment: We break down each visa option and recommend what fits based on goals and job role.
• Fast documentation: We prepare and file all documentation quickly with a fast two-week turnaround time, ensuring your petitions move forward quickly.

We understand that every immigration situation involves unique challenges, so we provide personalized attention tailored to your unique needs. Schedule a free consultation today!

Final Thoughts

Both the TN and H-1B visas serve important but different purposes. The TN visa works well for Canadian and Mexican citizens in listed professions who want a quicker, simpler entry into the U.S.

The H-1B visa offers more flexibility, especially for those considering a green card, working in non-NAFTA fields, or changing jobs over time. For professionals, the best choice is to pick a visa that supports both short-term success and long-term goals.

Are you not sure which visa option is right for you? Alma simplifies the process by guiding you through each step, from assessing your eligibility to preparing a strong petition for the right visa type. Get started with a free consultation now!

FAQs

Can I switch from a TN visa to an H-1B visa without leaving the U.S.?

You can change your status from TN to H-1B without leaving the United States by filing a Form I-129 (Petition for Nonimmigrant Worker) with USCIS. If approved, your status changes on the H-1B effective date. The petition must be selected in the lottery and approved before switching.

Can my spouse work in the U.S. if I have a TN or H-1B visa?

Spouses of TN visa holders receive TD (Trade Dependent) status, which does not permit employment. Spouses of H-1B holders receive H-4 status. They may be eligible to apply for work authorization (EAD) if the H-1B holder has an approved I-140 (Immigrant Petition) or has H-1B status beyond six years under AC21 provisions. H-1B is generally better for dual-career families.

What happens if my job title or responsibilities change while I'm on a TN or H-1B visa?

TN visa holders need a new TN application for any significant job changes, as the visa is tied to specific USMCA-listed categories. H-1B holders have more flexibility: minor changes may require only an updated LCA (Labor Condition Application), while significant changes need an amended H-1B petition. Wait for proper paperwork before implementing material changes.

‍